Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3 vs Priority Brilliant L-Train
Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3 and the Priority Brilliant L-Train are both bikes designed for urban riding, but they approach this task with different design philosophies. This detailed comparison will help you understand the unique characteristics of each model and determine which might better suit your urban cycling needs.
Comparison Table
| Feature | Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3 | Priority Brilliant L-Train |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $799.00 | $750.00 |
| Bike Type | Hybrid Bike | Hybrid Bike (Commuter) |
| Frame Material | Alpha Gold Aluminum | Chromoly steel |
| Wheel Size | 700c | 700c |
| Suspension | No Suspension | No Suspension |
| Drivetrain | Shimano | Shimano |
| Gearing | 18 gears | 7 gears |
| Brakes | Hydraulic Disc | V-Brakes |
| Weight | 26 lbs | 30 lbs. |
Price and Value
- Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3: $799.00
- Priority Brilliant L-Train: $750.00
The Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3 is $49 more expensive than the Priority Brilliant L-Train. This relatively small price difference suggests that both bikes are competing in a similar market segment, with the slight premium for the Trek possibly reflecting its disc brakes and wider gear range.
Bike Type and Frame Material
Both bikes are classified as hybrid bikes, designed for urban use, but they have different approaches:
- Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3: Hybrid Bike, Alpha Gold Aluminum
Trek’s Alpha Gold Aluminum is their higher-grade aluminum, known for its light weight and strength. It’s a step up from their standard aluminum frames. - Priority Brilliant L-Train: Hybrid Bike (Commuter), Chromoly steel
The L-Train uses a chromoly steel frame, known for its durability, comfort, and ability to absorb road vibrations. It’s designed specifically as a commuter bike, with geometry optimized for urban riding.
The choice of frame material significantly impacts the ride quality. The FX 2’s aluminum frame will likely feel more responsive and lighter, while the L-Train’s steel frame may offer a smoother, more comfortable ride, especially over rough urban surfaces.
Wheel Size
Both bikes feature 700c wheels, which are standard for road and hybrid bikes. This wheel size provides good rolling efficiency and speed on paved surfaces. The consistency in wheel size means that both bikes will have similar characteristics in terms of rolling resistance and the ability to maintain speed.
Suspension
Neither bike features suspension, which is typical for urban-focused bikes. The lack of suspension helps keep the weight down and improves pedaling efficiency on paved surfaces. This design choice indicates that both bikes are primarily intended for use on roads and smooth paths rather than rough terrain.
Drivetrain and Gearing
- Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3: Shimano, 18 gears
The FX 2 uses a traditional chain drive with a Shimano drivetrain offering 18 gears. This provides a wide range of gearing options for various urban riding conditions, including hills. - Priority Brilliant L-Train: Shimano, 7 gears
The L-Train features a belt drive system with a Shimano Nexus 7-speed internal gear hub. This system offers several advantages for urban riding: - Lower maintenance (no need to lubricate)
- Cleaner operation (no grease to get on clothes)
- Quieter ride
- Longer lifespan than traditional chains
While the L-Train offers fewer gears, the internal gear hub provides smooth shifting and is well-suited for urban riding conditions.
Brakes
- Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3: Hydraulic Disc
- Priority Brilliant L-Train: V-Brakes
This is a significant difference between the two bikes. The FX 2’s hydraulic disc brakes offer superior stopping power and better performance in all weather conditions. They typically require less finger effort to engage and provide better modulation.
The L-Train’s V-Brakes are simpler, lighter, and adequate for most urban riding conditions. However, they may not perform as well as disc brakes in wet conditions or on steep descents.
Weight
- Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3: 26 lbs
- Priority Brilliant L-Train: 30 lbs.
The Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3 is 4 pounds lighter than the Priority Brilliant L-Train. This weight difference is noticeable and could impact the bikes’ handling and ease of transport. The FX 2’s lighter weight could make it more agile and easier to accelerate, while also being easier to carry up stairs or lift onto a bike rack.
Riding Position and Comfort
Both bikes likely offer a relatively upright riding position, typical of urban-focused bikes:
- This position provides good visibility in traffic and comfort for shorter rides.
- The L-Train, being more commuter-focused, may offer a slightly more upright position for enhanced comfort and visibility in urban traffic.
The L-Train’s steel frame may provide a smoother ride by absorbing more road vibration, which could be beneficial for comfort on longer commutes.
Which is Better?
The choice between the Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3 and the Priority Brilliant L-Train depends on your specific needs and preferences:
- Maintenance: If you prioritize low maintenance, the L-Train’s belt drive and internal gear hub system is a significant advantage.
- Versatility: The FX 2, with its wider range of gears and disc brakes, offers more versatility for varied terrain and weather conditions.
- Braking Performance: The FX 2 has a clear advantage with its hydraulic disc brakes, especially in wet conditions or for riders who prioritize maximum stopping power.
- Weight: The FX 2 is significantly lighter, which could be important if you need to carry your bike frequently or prefer a more nimble ride.
- Ride Quality: The L-Train’s steel frame may offer a smoother ride, which could be preferable for riders prioritizing comfort, especially on longer commutes.
- Cleanliness: The L-Train’s belt drive system is cleaner to operate, which can be a significant advantage for commuters who ride in work clothes.
In conclusion, the Trek FX 2 Disc Gen 3 is the better choice for riders seeking a more versatile bike that can handle a variety of urban conditions and weather. Its hydraulic disc brakes, lighter weight, and wider gear range make it suitable for riders who prioritize performance and adaptability.
The Priority Brilliant L-Train is ideal for dedicated urban commuters who prioritize low maintenance, cleanliness, and comfort on relatively flat terrain. Its belt drive system and internal gear hub make it a reliable, clean, and quiet option for daily riding in the city.
Consider your primary riding purpose, the terrain of your typical routes, your maintenance preferences, and how much you value performance versus comfort when making your decision. Both bikes offer quality rides but cater to somewhat different needs within the urban cycling category.
